Atomfall Morris Wick choice explained – What’s the best option?

If you've come across Morris Wick in Atomfall, you're probably wondering whether you should report him, help him, or just ignore the whole thing.

His quest—part of the Murder in the Church storyline in Wyndham Village—is one of those choices that affects not only the story but also your rewards.

This guide breaks down everything you need to know about Morris Wick, what each option leads to, and what’s the smartest decision if you're trying to get the most out of your playthrough.

Who is Morris Wick in Atomfall and his location?

Image via Rebellion

Morris is the trader in Wyndham Village, and he seems friendly at first. But once you investigate the murder of Maisie in St. Katherine’s Church, things take a darker turn.

If you dig into the brewery cellar (watch out for rats), you’ll find a letter proving that Morris was behind Maisie’s death. The letter calls her the “Vicar’s spy” and tells Morris to silence her.

His location is 33.3E 79.8N.

Also Read: Atomfall: Optimized Setings

What are your options with Morris Wick in Atomfall?

Image via Rebellion

You can:

1. Report Morris to Captain Sims

• Sims is located in the village hall.
• He will accept your report but doesn’t really care who you blame, as long as you report someone.
• You’ll get access to Skethermoor Prison, but that’s about it.

Verdict: Least useful. You can do better.

2. Tell Vicar McHenry

• Found in St. Katherine’s Church.
• The Vicar will ask you to “deal with” Morris, meaning he wants you to kill him.
• If you do, he’ll give you a key to his upstairs chest, which contains an Atomic Battery. He’ll also give you a lead on a mansion in Casterfell Woods.

Verdict: Good reward, especially if you need that battery for story progress.

3. Talk to Morris directly

• Confront him in the trader’s shop.
• If you show him the letter and agree to keep his secret, he’ll give you a Master Crafting Manual.
• This unlocks skills like Gunsmith, Deep Pockets, and Crafting Speed.

Verdict: Best reward for gameplay—especially if you like upgrading gear.

The smartest path

You don’t have to pick just one path. Here’s the most rewarding way to handle it:

1. Tell the Vicar about Morris.
2. Then confront Morris and agree to keep his secret.
3. After you get the Crafting Manual, go ahead and kill Morris.
4. Go back to the Vicar to claim the Atomic Battery.
5. (Optional) After finishing everything, report the Vicar to Captain Sims.

This way, you get:

• The Crafting Manual from Morris
• The Atomic Battery from the Vicar
• Full access to Sims' next quest

Yes, you lose Morris as a trader, but there are others in the game, so it’s not a big deal.

Also Read: Atomfall: Barter system, explained

FAQs

Should I kill Morris Wick in Atomfall?

• If you want the best mix of rewards and story progress, yes. Just make sure to get the Crafting Manual from him first by pretending to help him.

What happens if I report Morris to Captain Sims?

• You’ll get access to Skethermoor, but Sims doesn’t give much else for it. He just wants someone to blame.

Can I still trade with Morris after confronting him?

• Yes, if you agree to keep his secret. But if you kill him or report him, you lose him as a trader. Trade with him first before doing anything drastic.

Is the Crafting Manual worth it?

• Absolutely. It unlocks key skills, especially Gunsmith, which is great for weapon upgrades.

Can I report both Morris and the Vicar?

• Yes. Once you’re done with the Vicar’s part of the quest, you can go back to Captain Sims and report the Vicar for covering up Maisie’s murder.